Which child do you love the most?
Any parent would say they love their children equally. But is it always true, wonders this dad of 2.

I am always suspicious of parents (actually I am suspicious of everyone, but parents are particularly tricky) when they claim to love their various children equally.

I understand that the question is quite a threatening one. If the child that was loved less understood this to be the case, he or she would still be nursing that injury 60 years from now. The child that was loved more might be consumed with guilt ... or grandiosity. The parent would feel weighed down with the awful burden; much better to say: ‘I love them each exactly the same’ and have done with it.

I have two boys, Jessie 14 and Tom 10. I have often circled the issue of whether I love one of them more than the other, and if so, which is the one I love more? Like most parent I would insist that I love both hugely and equally; but I am plagued by a sneaking suspicion that is not true.

I don't know if other people hide their emotions from themselves as much as I do, but I am something of an expert at not knowing what I really think.

Sometimes when I am making sandwiches or serving dinner I suddenly realise that I have, for some unaccountable reason, decided whose serving is whose. This is Jessie's, it's got the extra ham. This is Tom's, it's neater.

It is the damnedest thing - and I never know why I am doing what I am doing.

Do I love Jessie better? A deterministic Darwinism would predict that I would favour the one in whom I have invested the most. It makes evolutionary sense to care most for the older i.e. Jessie. But Tom is the baby, cuter, more gangly, he lisps and muddles his sentences. It's natural that I would feel more protective of him - he's more vulnerable.

Does it really matter?

Actually, I have finally come to the conclusion that this is just not as scary or as important as it sometimes looks or feels.

This is how I have resolved it for myself:

Firstly ‘love’ is a silly word. It contains so many different possible emotions and variations that it is impossible to know what we mean when we use the term.
Secondly, as a parent the emotions I am talking about are protectiveness, care and the 'hope that the child thrives' - now and as an adult. In that sense I can easily and clearly say I favour them equally.

Thirdly as a human being and at different times I feel different things about my boys. The emotions I am talking about here include delight, grief, happiness, yearning, disgust, affection, frustration, anxiety, guilt, humility, anger, delight, joy, amusement ... in fact all of the complex feelings one person is capable of feeling for another.

On any one day each child moves in and out of my affections and angers. There are also longer rhythms - periods of several weeks where Tom or Jessie is more amusing, interesting, irritable or irritating. But these feelings are constantly changing and shifting - with the ‘protectiveness, care and hope’ the background constant that is always present, no matter how bad or good other feelings get.

So I don't think there is anything 'wrong' with feeling different feelings for each child, at different times of the day or, on a bigger scale, at different times in your life and theirs.

And if one of them should benefit with an extra biscuit in the lunch box one day or suffer the manky piece of lettuce the next, well that's just life, isn't it?

Do you have a favourite child? Or were you a favourite?

Read more by Nic Borain

Disclaimer: The views of columnists published on Parent24 are their own and therefore do not necessarily represent the views of Parent24.

Read Parent24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.


Want to know what your baby looks like and what you can expect at this stage?



Everything from parties to pre-schools in your area.