Q&A with our ExpertsHave a question you don't know the answer to? Try Parent24 experts!
 
Do you know where you’re going to?Introducing the new Land Rover Discovery 2014
 
Search

“No kids, please, I’m depressed”

 
Could this woman’s decision to be child-free rob the world of potential genius?
By Scott Dunlop

Pic: Shutterstock

Article originally in Parents Corner
Sarah Silverman, a comedienne with a history of depression, recently stirred up debate by making the statement that she would not have kids, in order to avoid passing on any mental illness to biological children, according to Time Healthland.

The discussion generated by her statement is both in praise of the way she is taking responsibility as depression is hereditary- people with a parent or sibling who suffer from it are more susceptible to be sufferers themselves- and also critical, as the genes responsible for depression are also linked to creativity.

Genetic gambling or just optimism?

The point, writes Maia Szalavitz,  is that the “the same genes that can cause depression may also encourage the sensitivity and sensibility that gives Silverman her creative talent. Indeed, some research suggests that the same exact genetics that might lead to depression can also lead to mental superhealth, depending on whether a person endured high stress in early childhood or had a calmer, more nurturing environment.”

She argues that research has shown that while the environment in which someone is raised may affect the emergence of either depression or creativity, depending on whether the person is nurtured or neglected, although sometimes even a negative environment may result in the emergence of creative extremes.

Your future baby could be a genius!

Studies have been cited which link the presence of mood disorders and mental instability to creativity. For example, Szalavitz refers to a study of 300,000 Swedish families affected by psychiatric disorders found that people with bipolar disorder are overrepresented in creative professions. That same study showed that healthy relatives of people with schizophrenia are more likely to have creative careers.

So while it may be responsible of people who have such extreme mental illness that they are unable to function not to reproduce, if we attempt to avoid passing on these genes by not reproducing, we could also be depriving the world of possible creative genius.

Want more? Follow Scott and Parent24 on Twitter!


Which is better? Taking responsibility for not reproducing genes which result in depression, or taking the risk in the hopes that you will produce a special, gifted child?
Read more on: pregnant  |  special  |  conception  |  depression
NEXT ON PARENT24X

A mother after death?

2011-08-10 07:56

Read Parent24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
0 comments
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining
 
 
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.