Q&A: Which childcare options are better suited for my baby?
What are the pro’s and con’s of a) in-home childcare with a professional /nanny and b)a crèche?

In-home childcare


  • your child stays in their home environment - own bed, own toys, own routine
  • you have more control over your childs day
  • your child is not exposed to germs and illness from a very young age
  • there is no rush to get dressed and ready, baby can sleep in
  • baby builds a relationship with his caregiver
  • you know where baby is at all times and know he is getting the attention he needs
  • you don’t have to take time off work when baby is sick
  • if your caregiver drives, she can do some household errands such as grocery shopping, arranging clinic appointments and meeting you there, etc


  • there is no backup if your caregiver is ill
  • if your caregiver is not trained or experienced you might worry about the stimulation your child is getting
  • there is no-one at home to keep an eye on your caregiver - no peer support unless your caregiver joins a professional group of caregivers, etc
  • if your caregiver does not take initiative, you might find yourself constantly telling her what to do.

Crèche/Daycare (note - not a nursery school)


  • more than one leader per class so there is cover if the caregiver gets ill
  • in some cases, the caregivers are trained in childcare and education
  • your child receives stimulation
  • crèches with webcams allow you to see your baby during the day


  • exposure to germs, illness, etc, on a daily basis
  • your child will have to share attention with several other little ones, which is difficult for them in the first 2 - 3 years
  • a rush in the mornings to get ready and to crèche on time
  • you have little to no control over your childs day
  • some crèches will change your childs daily routine
  • your child sleeps in a communal nursery so may be disturbed by other babies
  • your child may be over-stimulated and battle to wind down and sleep at home

Read Parent24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Everything from parties to pre-schools in your area.